Risk Management · 2024
In this section2 topics
Risk Management Policy & Plan
Policy & Plan Description
PRTR is committed to conducting business with stability and sustainability, therefore, we are well aware of the importance of assessing organizational risks, both reviewing and developing risk management plans regularly under uncertainty, both in terms of social, economic, environmental, and various technological changes that are rapidly changing today. In order for the business to be sustainable and successful according to the organization's goals, risk management is an extremely important foundation, whether it is the process of risk identification, risk assessment, as well as finding measures to control, monitor, and review risks regularly. To ensure that if new risks arise, the company will be able to manage the risks that may occur to be within the criteria that the company can accept. In order for various departments in the company to have guidelines for risk management in the same direction, PRTR has established guidelines to comply with PRTR's risk management policy as follows:
1) PRTR is committed to good corporate governance by adopting the Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) framework in accordance with the COSO (The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission) Risk Management Framework, which is an international standard risk management guideline, to be used as a guideline for risk management of the Company and its subsidiaries, which the Board of Directors, executives, and employees at all levels must comply with the risk management policy to ensure effective and efficient risk management.
2) PRTR will prepare a risk register in accordance with the COSO ERM guidelines and review it at least once a year. PRTR will prepare and review to manage risks to an acceptable level or deviate no more than the level that PRTR accepts.
Risk Management Structure
The Company has defined the roles and responsibilities for risk management as follows:
1) The Board of Directors is responsible for supporting, promoting, overseeing risk management, and approving the risk management policy. Ensure that the Company and its subsidiaries have adequate and appropriate management of risks that may have a material impact and understand the risks that may have a material impact on the Company.
2) The Audit and Risk Management Committee is responsible for independently overseeing and monitoring risk management, reviewing the internal control system to ensure that the Company and its subsidiaries have adequate and appropriate enterprise risk management. Communicate with the Executive Committee to understand key risks linked to internal control and internal audit. Report to the Board of Directors on risks and risk management at least annually.
3) The Executive Committee has overall responsibility for the organization's risk management, considers and approves the risk management policy, and submits it to the Audit and Risk Management Committee for consideration and approval before submitting it to the Board of Directors for further approval. Approve the risk management framework and risk management plan. Monitor the development of the risk management framework and the risk identification and assessment process. Communicate with the Audit and Risk Management Committee on key risks and report to the Audit and Risk Management Committee on risks and risk management at least annually.
4) The Chief Executive Officer is responsible for preparing and reviewing the risk management policy, company regulations on risk management to be consistent with the changing situation, and submitting them to the Executive Committee for consideration and approval. Monitor significant risks, ensure that there is an adequate and appropriate risk management plan, as well as support, promote, implement the risk management policy, and ensure that the risk management process is implemented throughout the company.
5) The Risk Management Working Group conducts risk assessments and oversees various departments to comply with the risk management plan by establishing appropriate criteria, processes, and measures, including holding regular follow-up meetings to enable the company to manage risks effectively and in accordance with good corporate governance guidelines.
6) The risk management officer of the department is responsible for ensuring that a framework, work plan, and risk management process are in place for the department and submit them to the Executive Committee for approval, support, and follow up on the risk management of the department under their responsibility, including promoting and encouraging employees to be aware of the importance of risk management.
7) Personnel at all levels and departments of PRTR are responsible for identifying, measuring, controlling, monitoring, and reporting risks related to their work to the risk management officer of the department and jointly developing a risk management plan and implementing the plan.
8) The Internal Audit is responsible for reviewing the internal control system and ensuring that the Company has implemented an appropriate and company-wide risk management system, has adequate and appropriate internal controls to manage risk, and that such internal controls are effectively implemented. Review the performance of risk management, including communicating and understanding with management and auditees about risks to plan risk-based audits.
Risk Type
The Company has assessed and categorized the relevant risks as follows:
1) Strategic Risk Refers to the risk that may affect the set strategy not going according to the operational plan, such as the company's lack of human resources, which may not be able to support business expansion or dependence on executives, etc.
2) Operational Risk Refers to the risks arising from operational processes that may directly affect operations and business objectives, such as the risk of personnel shortage from high resignation rates, reliance on skilled personnel, delayed or incorrect service delivery, as well as the expansion of the customer base and market share to meet targets, etc.
3) Financial Risk Refers to risks related to financial liquidity, financial management, and budgeting, such as the risk of inappropriate budgeting, insufficient working capital, and the risk of counterparties not fulfilling their obligations (Credit Risk) or interest rate volatility, etc.
4) Information Technology Risk Refers to the risk of loss of employee and information assets, which are the main assets of the company. The risk of misuse of information, the risk of computer system failures, prolonged interruptions affecting operations, and the credibility of the company, etc.
5) Compliance Risk Refers to the risk of changes in relevant laws, regulations, and rules or the inability to comply with relevant laws, regulations, and rules that may affect the Company's business operations, etc.
6) Fraud and Corruption Risk Refers to the risk that may arise for unlawful gain, such as receiving or giving bribes, gifts, or financial assistance, etc., both directly or indirectly, in order to obtain undue benefits, etc.
7) Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Risk Refers to risks related to environmental, social, and governance factors that may impact business operations and the sustainability of the organization. Environmental risks arise from changes in the environment and related regulations, which may affect operational processes, resources, and business costs. Social risks relate to labor issues, human rights, the health and safety of employees and stakeholders, as well as relationships with the community and society. While governance risks arise from ineffective oversight, lack of transparency, or unethical business conduct, which may affect investor confidence and the organization's reputation.
8) Emerging Risk Refers to losses arising from risks that are not currently apparent but may arise in the future due to changing circumstances. This type of risk is a slow-onset risk that is difficult to identify, has a low frequency of occurrence, but when it does occur, it has a severe impact. This emerging risk is often the result of political, legal, social, technological, physical environmental, or natural changes. Sometimes, the impact of this type of risk may not be identifiable at present. For example, problems arising from natural disasters or epidemics, etc.
Policy Document Link
https://investor.prtr.com/storage/downloads/corporate-governance/corporate-policies/prtr-risk-management-policy-th.pdf
Risks to the Company's Business Operations
Risk Register
| Risk Name | Risk Characteristics | Consequences | Management Measures | Related Risk Factors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Strategic Risk: Risk of lack of Brand Awareness in the HR business | The company may face challenges in building brand awareness among its target audience. The HR (Human Resources) industry is highly competitive with numerous service providers, making it difficult for the company's brand to stand out and be memorable in the market. Furthermore, without a clear and effective marketing strategy, the company will be unable to differentiate itself from competitors, impacting its ability to attract new customers and retain existing ones. | • Business opportunities decrease If the target group is unaware of or unfamiliar with the company's brand, the company may lose opportunities to expand its new customer base, which is essential for organizational growth. Failure to build good awareness can lead to a decrease in sales or revenue due to a lack of contact from new customers or businesses. • Competitiveness decreases The company may experience a loss of competitiveness, especially in markets with well-known competitors. The lack of a unique identity or differentiation in the market may lead customers to choose services from competitors with greater reputation or stronger marketing, which will prevent the company from expanding its business. | Develop a business development and market expansion strategy (Business Development Strategy). Provide useful and relevant information to the target group. Utilize social media to increase reach and build relationships with the target audience. This includes conducting Public Relations (PR) to gain brand mentions in appropriate media. | 728 · Description: Volatility in the industry in which the company operates · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Strategic Risk: Risk of not being able to deliver services as expected by customers | The company may not be able to deliver services that meet customer expectations. This may be due to several reasons such as unclear understanding of customer needs or service delivery that does not meet standards, resulting in services that do not meet customer expectations. This risk may cause customers to be dissatisfied and decide to stop using the service or find a new service provider. | • Loss of customers and trust If the services provided do not meet expectations, customers may be dissatisfied and choose to use services from competitors, which may affect the company's revenue and reputation. • Impact on corporate image Receiving complaints or negative feedback from customers may damage the company's reputation, especially if opinions are shared online or on social media. | • Regularly hold meetings with customers to listen to their feedback, expectations, and suggestions regarding services, as well as conduct regular Customer Satisfaction Surveys to assess service quality and identify areas for improvement. | 729 · Description: Behavior or needs of customers / consumers · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Strategic Risk: Risk of changes in labor demand in the industry | Changes in labor demand in the industry may impact the company's revenue. A decrease in labor demand in certain industries, such as the technology industry or industries adapting to new trends, could lead to the company losing a significant source of revenue and potentially affecting the company's financial stability. | • Revenue decrease If the industries that the Company relies on experience a decrease in labor demand or changes in service requirements, the Company may lose customers in those industries, resulting in a decline in revenue from that customer group. | • Customer Base Diversification Across Industries: The company has implemented a strategy to diversify its customer base across multiple industries to reduce reliance on any single industry. This includes expanding the PC (Personal Computer) customer base into new sectors such as healthcare, education, and services. • Customer Surveys and Meetings: The company conducts regular monthly satisfaction surveys and meetings with customers. This is to monitor customer needs and tailor services to meet expectations, aiming to maintain a customer retention rate of no less than 95%. | 729 · Description: Behavior or needs of customers / consumers · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Operational Risk: Risk of Outsource Staff Shortages | Currently, more than 95% of service revenue comes from the Outsource business, which covers the recruitment of outsource employees, the management of employees to meet the needs of each customer, as well as the preparation and payment of salaries and employee training to be able to fully meet the diverse needs of customers. Therefore, personnel are an important mechanism to drive the company's business. It can be seen that in the past period from 2020-2024, the number of PRTR's outsource employees has increased continuously, which is in line with the growth of revenue from services - Outsource business, as follows: • Number of Outsource Employees (persons) Over the past 5 years, the number of the company's outsource employees has grown continuously. In 2020, the number of outsource employees was 12,586 and increased to 19,022 in 2024, reflecting the continuous expansion of the number of employees hired by the company through outsourcing, especially in 2024, which increased by more than 13% from the previous year. • Revenue from services - Outsource business (million baht) Revenue from Outsource services has increased every year. In 2020, revenue was 4,679.5 million baht and increased to 7,055.0 million baht in 2024. In 2023, revenue from the Outsource business increased slightly by 4.0% compared to 2022. However, in 2024, there was a high growth of 15.6%, which is considered the highest growth in the past 5 years. The nature of the human resources outsourcing services business (HR Outsourcing Services or Outsource) is typical of businesses that have to manage a large number of employees. There is a variety of job positions and industries in which employees must work at the customer's workplace. Therefore, it is normal to have employees coming in and out. - Employees who resign to work elsewhere or pursue other occupations. - It comes from the normal course of business that the employment contract will have a term of employment equal to the term of the service agreement with the customer (Back to Back), so that when the contract expires and the project ends, the employee will resign voluntarily to find a new job. - Increased recruitment of employees both in the short term during festivals (Seasonal) or long term. - Transferring employees to work with client companies, in which case the client company must pay a conversion fee to PRTR. The nature of the business results in PRTR having a high turnover rate of more than 50%. Therefore, recruiting employees to maintain the number of employees in each category to meet customer needs is very important to PRTR. If PRTR cannot find employees with the qualifications and numbers to meet customer needs, | • Service quality and reputation If the company fails to comply with the agreement with the customer, which may result in a breach of contract, and may have to pay a fine, the customer may terminate the contract or not renew the contract. • Impact on net profit If customer loss or high penalties occur due to a breach of contract, the company will lose both revenue and net profit, which may affect the company's financial stability. | • Regularly prepare recruitment plans with clients to be able to recruit employees with specific expertise to match the job positions and qualifications required by the clients according to the plan. • There is an outsourced recruitment team to support business expansion. As of December 31, 2017, PRTR had 128 employees working in outsourced recruitment. The outsourced recruitment team will recruit employees according to the qualifications required by customers through various online and offline methods, such as posting job advertisements through the PRTR Website, job websites, and various social media channels, employee network line groups, employee network Facebook groups, creating referral networks, setting up booths at various locations such as communities near workplaces, educational institutions, or universities, participating in job fairs, etc. This also includes a database of more than 650,000 applicants, which comes from the history of those who have applied for jobs through PRTR and leading job websites. • Provide training in important skills, whether soft skills or skills specific to that job. PRTR will coordinate training, whether by PRTR or through the Blacksmith by PRTR platform, as well as invite external personnel or send them to training at relevant agencies to continuously develop the company's work potential. • There is a policy of paying fair and appropriate compensation to employees at all levels based on experience, employee performance, and PRTR's performance. PRTR conducts salary and benefits surveys and can advise clients on appropriate employee compensation as well as maintain timely payment of compensation as agreed. • PRTR has good benefits and an experienced team to provide appropriate advice and support to employees. We have a PRTR coordinator team that takes care of labor relations between employees and clients. They will talk to employees regularly to listen to any comments or questions they may have, clarify or resolve any conflicts that may arise, provide a complaint hotline, organize annual parties, coordinate with banks to provide employees with access to home loans or personal loans to reduce the impact of informal loans, provide accidental death insurance to employees, provide financial assistance in case of family death, and other benefits such as store discounts, etc. | 739 · Description: Shortage or reliance on skilled workers · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Operational Risk : Payment of compensation to employees according to the Labor Protection Act B.E. 2541 | The payment of compensation to employees under the Labor Protection Act B.E. 2541 stipulates that compensation must be paid upon the termination of the contract or dismissal. As outsourced employees are employees of PRTR (PRTR is the employer under the law), if compensation is not paid to employees in accordance with the Labor Protection Act B.E. 2541, PRTR will be liable under the law. | • Legal Consequences If the company fails to pay compensation in accordance with the Labor Protection Act B.E. 2541, it may be subject to lawsuits or penalties from relevant authorities due to non-compliance with legal requirements. This could result in legal expenses for the company and potential damage to its reputation. | • Closely monitor the matter. The employment contract will specify the employment period equal to the service contract period with the client (Back to Back) to ensure a mutual understanding between PRTR and the employee that the client's project has an end date. Upon the expiration of the contract and project, the employee will voluntarily resign to seek new employment. In such cases, PRTR is not required to pay severance pay under Section 118 as it is a voluntary resignation. In the past, in such cases, PRTR has not had to pay severance pay, and this trend is likely to continue in the future. However, if the termination occurs before the project ends, PRTR is legally obligated to pay severance pay. PRTR can recover almost all of the severance pay from the client, as stipulated in the client contract. However, if the employee's conduct falls under the circumstances of termination without severance pay according to Section 119 of the Labor Protection Act B.E. 2541, as follows, PRTR is not required to pay severance pay: (1) Dishonesty in the performance of duties or intentional criminal offenses against the employer. (2) Intentional acts that cause damage to the employer. (3) Negligence causing serious damage to the employer. (4) Violation of work regulations, employer's rules, or lawful and fair orders, and the employer has given a written warning, except in serious cases where a written warning is not required. The warning letter shall be valid for no more than 1 year from the date the client commits the violation. (5) Abandonment of duty for 3 consecutive working days, whether or not there are holidays in between, without reasonable cause. (6) Imprisonment by a final court judgment, except for offenses committed by negligence or petty offenses. In addition, PRTR has legal counsel specializing in labor law to provide advice on various aspects to ensure compliance with relevant laws. | 741 · Description: Systems or internal control system · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Operational Risk : Risk from the shortage of permanent employees at PRTR's office | The shortage of office staff at PRTR is a significant risk, as office staff play a vital role in supporting the Outsource and Recruitment businesses by working that requires contact with customers and coordinating the recruitment of employees, as well as solving problems within a limited timeframe. If there is insufficient office staff or a lack of necessary skills, it may not be possible to provide services to customers as expected, which will affect the company's ability to operate. The turnover rate of employees after passing the 119-day probationary period for the years 2022, 2023, and 2024 are as follows: 1. Number of office staff at the end of the year • Year 2022: Total number of employees 595 • Year 2023: Total number of employees 590 • Year 2024: Total number of employees 598 2. Resignations during the year • Year 2022: Number of resigned employees 213 • Year 2023: Number of resigned employees 240 • Year 2024: Number of resigned employees 175 3. % Turnover Rate • Year 2022: Turnover rate 41.6% • Year 2023: Turnover rate 40.5% • Year 2024: Turnover rate 29.46% Note: Turnover Rate is calculated by dividing the number of employees who resigned during the year by the average number of employees at the end of the current and previous years. | • Decline in service quality. A shortage of office staff or staff unfamiliar with the nature of the work may result in an inability to manage and serve customers to the standards they expect. This could lead to customer dissatisfaction and reduced confidence in PRTR's services. • Delays in work. The lack of specialized office personnel may lead to an inability to meet customer needs promptly, resulting in service delays. This could cause PRTR to lose business opportunities and experience customer retention issues. | In the past, the turnover rate was quite high due to the aforementioned reasons. However, PRTR acknowledges this risk and has implemented the following measures to prevent risks from labor shortages and reduce employee turnover: • Provide a mentoring system for new employees. • Enhance the recruitment process to better align with job requirements. • Regularly prepare a recruitment plan by recruiting employees with specific expertise to match the job positions and meet the qualifications required by clients. • Provide training on essential skills, including both soft skills and job-specific skills. PRTR will coordinate training, whether conducted by PRTR itself or through the Blacksmith by PRTR platform. External personnel will be invited, or employees will be sent for training at relevant organizations to continuously develop the company's workforce potential. • Pay fair and equitable compensation to employees at all levels, commensurate with their experience and performance, including PRTR's overall performance. PRTR has incorporated data from its internal Salary and Benefits Survey to determine employee compensation. PRTR also ensures timely payment of compensation as agreed upon, without any improper deductions beyond the employment contract or those not in accordance with the law. The employment contracts have been reviewed by legal counsel. • Provide appropriate benefits to ensure a good quality of life for employees. Various benefits are provided, including health insurance, life and accident insurance, provident fund, annual health check-ups, etc. Overall, the turnover rate in 2023 decreased to 29.46% from 40.5% in 2022. The company has considered various activities and projects to support and enhance organizational commitment, such as the Employee Joint Investment Program (EJIP), along with other ongoing activities. | 739 · Description: Shortage or reliance on skilled workers · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Operational Risk : Risk from increasing Outsource employee costs | The primary cost for PRTR is the compensation of outsourced employees. Therefore, the increase in the minimum wage according to the law may result in an increase in PRTR's costs. On December 23, 2014, the Wage Committee issued the Wage Committee Notification Re: Minimum Wage Rate (No. 13) to determine the minimum wage rate to be effective from January 1, 2015, onwards. This resulted in an average minimum wage of 355.58 Baht per day, an increase of 2.9 percent compared to the previous year. When considering each province, the provinces that received a minimum wage of 400.00 Baht were Phuket, Chachoengsao, Chonburi, Rayong, and Koh Samui District, Surat Thani Province. The minimum wage of 380 Baht was specific to Mueang Chiang Mai District, Chiang Mai Province, and Hat Yai District, Songkhla Province. These 7 areas adjusted their wages by an additional 30 to 55 Baht per day, while other areas increased by 7 and 9 Baht per day compared to the previous year. This new minimum wage rate may result in increased costs for the company, which may affect the company's operating results. | • Increased costs The increase in the minimum wage will increase PRTR's outsourced employee costs, which could impact the company's overall costs. If the company cannot control these costs, it could result in a decrease in net profit. | • Passing on costs to customers: Due to the structure of PRTR's contracts with customers, which allows for billing based on actual costs incurred, such as minimum wage and various benefits, PRTR can fully pass on the increased costs to customers. In the past, PRTR has not encountered any issues with passing on such costs to customers. Furthermore, the increase in the minimum wage will have a positive impact on PRTR by increasing service revenue. • Effective cost management: Consider effective cost management to reduce unnecessary costs in other areas. This will enable the company to cope with the increased costs from the minimum wage without impacting operational results. | 755 · Other name: Government policy on minimum wage payment · Description: Other · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Operational Risk : Risk of Non-Renewal | The primary revenue-generating business for PRTR is the provision of outsourced personnel. The nature of these contracts is continuous, meaning that if clients are satisfied with the quality and comprehensive services provided by PRTR, and there are no conditions necessitating the termination of services, they will continue to utilize PRTR's services. Although PRTR does not rely on any single client for more than 30% of its total revenue, if several major clients were to not renew their contracts, it could potentially impact the company's revenue and net profit. However, with PRTR's strengths stemming from its long-standing experience in this business and its corporate culture of working closely with clients as a business partner, we possess a deep understanding of our clients' organizational cultures and needs. We are always prepared to assist in resolving any situation as a unified team. This approach has resulted in a high level of client satisfaction, with a contract renewal rate of approximately 95%. The majority of our clients are existing customers who consistently choose to renew their contracts with PRTR. | • Loss of revenue and profit If customers do not renew their contracts, it may cause an immediate decrease in service revenue, which will directly impact the company's net profit. | • Customer Satisfaction from the Start: Before providing services, signing contracts, or making changes to orders, PRTR will acknowledge and understand the client's requirements clearly. Discussions are held to present and ensure clients understand the details of the service before proceeding. • Customer Relationship Management: Regular meetings are held with clients to listen to problems, changing needs, and solutions. • Division of Work: Teams are structured to cover all processes. - The Sales Department oversees the overall project, monitors feedback, and addresses customer issues. - The Human Resources Department takes care of employee recruitment and plans with clients to ensure smooth business operations. - The Human Resources Department, which manages employees, handles orientation, compensation, payroll, and benefits. They work closely with clients to ensure that employees can work efficiently for the smooth operation of the client's business. | 755 · Other name: Service contract renewal · Description: Other · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Operational Risk: Risk of errors and losses from the work performed by employees sent to work with customers (Outsourced employees) | The performance of Outsource employees may sometimes result in errors or damages during their work. PRTR and the client will jointly consider whether the damage is a direct result of errors made by PRTR's employees or due to errors arising from following the client's instructions. If the damage arises from following the client's instructions, PRTR will not be held liable. However, in cases where defects and damages arise from the negligence of Outsource employees, whether intentional or unintentional, or from cases of fraud, embezzlement, or deception, PRTR shall be liable for compensation to the client. Subsequently, PRTR will proceed to collect the compensation from the employee. This is because Outsource employees are considered employees of PRTR and are under the direct responsibility of PRTR. | • Financial Impact If damages occur for which PRTR is liable to compensate customers, the significant value of such damages could impact the company's revenue and net profit, including its financial liquidity. This is because the company would need to compensate customers for damages first. • Impact on Reputation Damages caused by outsourced employees may lead to customer dissatisfaction and loss of trust in PRTR, negatively impacting the company's reputation and image in the market. This could result in the company losing existing customers or failing to attract new ones. | PRTR acknowledges this potential risk, and should any damage occur that PRTR is liable for and the value is material, it could impact PRTR's revenue and net profit, as well as its reputation and liquidity. Therefore, PRTR has arranged comprehensive insurance coverage to mitigate the risk of potential damages caused by outsourced employees as follows: - General Liability / Miscellaneous Accident Policy - Fidelity Guarantee Insurance for employees as specified by customers or in accordance with the nature of each job type, such as salespeople, accounting staff, and employees handling high-value assets. (The insurance company will compensate the employer for the actual amount of damage directly resulting from fraudulent acts, embezzlement, or misconduct by the insured person, detected during the insurance period.) - Miscellaneous Professional Liability Insurance In addition, PRTR has taken out insurance coverage as stipulated in the service agreements between PRTR and certain customers. These agreements specify the insured amount for performance guarantees to cover any potential damages. They also mandate relevant insurance coverage for specific amounts, such as Public Liability Insurance, which covers liabilities arising within the business premises or from the insured's operations, and General Liability Insurance. PRTR believes that the aforementioned insurance coverage is sufficient and adequately covers potential damages arising from such risks. | 742 · Description: Human error in business operations · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Operational Risk : Risk from natural disasters that affect operations | Natural disasters such as floods, earthquakes, or other calamities may impact employee performance, infrastructure, information technology systems, and overall business operations. This could lead to service disruptions, affect the ability to fulfill customer contracts, and cause damage to company assets. | • Service disruption If a severe natural disaster occurs, the company may not be able to provide services to customers as agreed. This could affect customer satisfaction and may result in contract cancellations or non-renewals. • Damage to infrastructure and assets Natural disasters can damage company property or infrastructure, such as buildings, offices, or critical equipment. This could prevent the company from operating normally and require time for repairs or restoration. • Impact on information technology systems The company's information technology (IT) systems may be damaged by natural disasters, which could disrupt employee work and customer service. This could lead to the loss of important data or the inability to access necessary information. | To address this risk, the Company has established a Business Continuity Plan (BCP), which is an important guideline in mitigating the impact of natural disasters and defining response measures to enable the company to operate continuously even in emergency situations. Key measures implemented include: - Business Impact Analysis (BIA) by assessing the severity of natural disasters that may affect the organization in various aspects such as damage to the workplace, IT systems, and critical infrastructure, as well as identifying critical business processes that need to be restored first in order to resume operations quickly, such as customer service, management of critical databases, and support systems essential for operations. - Define a Business Recovery Strategy by preparing alternative work locations to accommodate emergencies or support Work from Home (WFH) to enable employees to work remotely continuously. In addition, the company has implemented measures to back up data and IT systems to prevent data loss, as well as planned system recovery to be able to return to use quickly and efficiently. | 1719 · Description: Climate change and disasters · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 1720 · Description: System disruption risk · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Financial Risk: Risk of late payment from debtors | The company faces risks from debtors who make late payments or are unable to settle their debts according to the agreed-upon terms, which could lead to bad debts and impact financial liquidity. This risk may arise from various factors, such as the financial problems of customers, some of whom may lack liquidity or experience financial difficulties, resulting in payment delays. In addition, external factors such as economic recession or changes in market conditions may affect customers' cash flow and lead to payment delays as well. | • Loss of Revenue and Cash Flow Late payments or non-payments of debts can cause companies to lose cash flow necessary for business operations, resulting in the company's inability to use funds for investments or important operations. • Bad debts Debtors who fail to make payments on time will lead to revenue loss in the form of bad debts, which can directly impact the company's net profit and may require an increase in allowance for doubtful accounts. | To manage and mitigate the risk of late payments from customers, the Company has established clear measures. - Credit Granting Criteria: The Company establishes clear credit granting criteria by considering the financial history, debt repayment ability, and business stability of new customers. For existing customers, credit terms are reviewed upon contract renewal. This practice mitigates the risk of extending credit to customers who may default on their payments. - Standardized Debt Collection System: The Company implements a standardized debt collection system, including the preparation of a monthly Aging Report to monitor the status of accounts receivable and determine appropriate debt collection strategies. Additionally, a monthly report on debtors and payment status is submitted to management to facilitate timely planning and mitigation of potential issues. In cases of persistent late payments, the Company employs debt collection measures such as phone calls, emails, or warning letters. If these measures prove ineffective, legal action may be considered to address outstanding debts appropriately. | 763 · Description: Default on payment or exchange of goods · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK |
| Financial Risk: Liquidity Risk | Financial liquidity risk is a risk that may affect the Company's ability to operate its business. If cash flow cannot be managed effectively, there may be problems in paying short-term debts or continuing operations, especially in the event of unforeseen events such as late payments from customers, economic changes, or emergency expenses. As of December 31, 2023 and 2024, PRTR had a liquidity ratio of 4.7 times and 4.2 times, respectively. PRTR had cash and cash equivalents as of December 31, 2023 and 2024, amounting to 480.3 million baht and 477.8 million baht. With future cash flow from operations and unused credit facilities as of December 31, 2023, including a promissory note (P/N) facility totaling 550.0 million baht and an overdraft facility of 30.0 million baht. For the debt-to-equity ratio (D/E Ratio) as of December 31, 2023 and 2024, it is at 0.4 times, the same for both years. In addition, PRTR currently has no interest-bearing loans. From the cash flow from operations, cash and cash equivalents, and the aforementioned debt-to-equity ratio, combined with close cash flow management every week, the management is confident that PRTR will have sufficient working capital for current needs and for the next 12 months. | • Impact on business continuity: If a company lacks liquidity, it may be unable to pay recurring or emergency expenses, such as employee salaries or customer service-related expenses, impacting business continuity. • Loss of credibility: Lack of liquidity may cause a company to lose credibility in the eyes of partners, customers, and financial institutions, especially if it is unable to make payments on time. | - Close cash flow management PRTR closely manages liquidity by planning and monitoring cash flow weekly to manage working capital efficiently. - Short-term and long-term financial planning Capital expenditures are planned in advance, including the preparation of financial projections to forecast cash flow continuously, helping to prepare for possible situations. | 1724 · Description: Liquidity risk · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK |
| Information Technology Risks : Risks from Cyber Threats | Cyber threats are a risk that can impact the security of the company's information systems. Cyberattacks, such as data breaches or system intrusions, can occur through various channels, such as unauthorized access to critical information, data leakage, or attacks that disrupt system operations, especially when the system is connected to public networks or the internet. The company must constantly address these evolving and complex threats. | • Loss of Critical Data: Cyberattacks can lead to the loss or leakage of sensitive information, such as customer data, financial information, or data related to company operations. This can damage customer and partner trust, as well as result in lawsuits or penalties under privacy and data protection regulations. • System Disruption: Cyberattacks can cause company systems to malfunction or be disrupted, resulting in service outages for customers. This can impact business operations and reduce employee productivity. | - Information Technology Security Policy The company has established a strict information technology security policy and has been certified to ISO 27001, an international standard for information security management systems, to ensure that best security practices are followed. - IT Security Awareness Training The company regularly communicates and trains employees on IT Security Awareness to increase knowledge and awareness about data security, such as avoiding opening suspicious emails or following security practices when using the system. - Network Segmentation The company has implemented clear internal and external network segmentation to prevent unauthorized access to critical information from the outside and reduce the risk of attacks that may arise from public networks. - Penetration Testing The company conducts penetration testing to assess the vulnerabilities of systems connected to public networks and test the security of the system to withstand cyberattacks. | 744 · Description: Information security and cyber-attack · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Information Technology Risk: Risk of information leakage or loss | The leakage or loss of sensitive information can occur due to various reasons, such as unauthorized data access, poor data management, or the use of insecure passwords. This can impact data security, lead to violations of data protection regulations (e.g., GDPR or PDPA), and diminish the organization's credibility in the eyes of customers, partners, and stakeholders. | • Data security breaches. The leakage of critical information may result in the unauthorized disclosure or access to sensitive or personal customer data, impacting data security and potentially leading to data breaches. | - Password Setting Improvement: The company has improved password settings to be more secure, such as using complex passwords and enforcing regular password change policies to prevent unauthorized access. - User Account Control: The company has implemented user account control by separating employee accounts from privileged accounts. This limits access to sensitive information and high-risk systems, reducing the chances of unauthorized access to unnecessary data. - Inactive Account Deletion: Inactive or unattended user accounts are regularly deleted from the system to mitigate the risk of unauthorized access from unused accounts. - Privileged Account Management Process: The company has established a process for managing privileged user accounts, such as Administrator accounts or accounts that can access critical information. This process includes strict monitoring and control of usage, as well as logging all activities for auditing and tracking purposes. | 744 · Description: Information security and cyber-attack · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Information Technology Risks : Risks from Information Technology System Failure | Information Technology (IT) Systems are essential to the company's operations, including data management, internal communication, and customer service. The risk of system failures or disruptions, whether due to hardware, software, power outages, or other disasters, could result in business interruption. | • Operational Disruption: If the information system fails, employees may not be able to access core systems such as accounting, payroll, or customer databases, resulting in business disruption or delays. | - Develop an Information System Disaster Recovery Plan (DRP). The company has developed a Disaster Recovery Plan (DRP) as a guideline for responding to unexpected events. It specifies the steps for inspection, recovery, and restoration of the system to be back in operation quickly and safely. - Establishing IT policies. The company has established IT policies to govern practices related to data storage, usage, and control, including the assignment of appropriate data access rights to enhance system security. | 755 · Other name: Cloud Information System · Description: Other · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Legal Risk: Risks arising from non-compliance or inconsistencies with laws, regulations, and rules. | The company has regularly developed and reviewed Work Instructions to ensure that work processes comply with relevant standards and regulations. In addition, legal counsel has been hired to review and advise on compliance practices. | • Compliance risk is the risk that may arise from non-compliance with relevant standards or requirements. This may be due to a lack of understanding of legal requirements, outdated operating manuals, or a lack of effective internal controls. Non-compliance may expose the company to legal risks that affect business operations. | - Prepare and review work instructions. The company regularly prepares and reviews work instructions to ensure that each work process complies with relevant laws and regulations, including established standards. - Hiring legal counsel. The company hires legal counsel to advise on compliance with applicable laws and regulations and to help review relevant practices to ensure that the company complies with the law fully. | 758 · Description: Violations of laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK |
| Legal Risks: Risks arising from non-compliance with Personal Data Protection Laws | Personal data breaches are a potential risk arising from the collection, use, or disclosure of personal data without consent or data handling that does not comply with the Personal Data Protection Act B.E. 2562 (PDPA). This can occur due to employee ignorance, negligence, or misunderstanding, including a lack of effective control systems for managing personal data held by the company. | • Legal Violations and Penalties: If the company handles personal data incorrectly or not in accordance with the PDPA, it may result in legal penalties such as administrative fines or lawsuits by data subjects. • Reputational Damage: Personal data breaches can cause customers, partners, or employees to lose trust in the company, impacting its image and credibility in the long run. | - Policy Development and Training: The company has established a personal data protection policy in accordance with the PDPA and regularly conducts training for employees at all levels on compliance with the law and personal data protection policies. This ensures that employees are aware of the importance of data privacy and act accordingly. - Access Control and Personal Data Management: Access rights are granted on a need-to-know basis, and secure data management procedures are in place to prevent unauthorized access. | 758 · Description: Violations of laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK |
| Risks of Fraud and Corruption: Offering gifts, entertainment, or contributions to government agencies in a manner that could be considered bribery | The risks associated with providing gifts, entertainment, or donations to government agencies may lead to conflicts of interest or improper benefits to government officials, which could violate anti-corruption laws and potentially impact the company's business operations. | • Legal violations and lawsuits: If the company is found to be involved in bribery or corruption, it may face legal action, potentially resulting in fines or lawsuits. • Loss of reputation: Involvement in bribery or corruption can severely damage the company's reputation and image, leading to a loss of trust among customers, partners, and stakeholders. | - Anti-Corruption Policy and Training: The Company has established an anti-corruption policy that sets guidelines for giving and receiving gifts, entertainment, donations, and sponsorships. The Company also provides regular training and communicates the policy to employees to raise awareness and prevent violations. - Whistle-blowing and Complaint Channels: The Company has established whistle-blowing and complaint channels via email. Whistle-blowing@prtr.com which can be sent directly to the Chairman of the Audit Committee, so that employees can report inappropriate or unethical events without fear of retaliation. | 754 · Description: Corruption · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| ESG risks | 1) Environmental Risk The company may face risks from climate change and operations that do not comply with environmental laws or regulations, which may affect business operations and the company's image. 2) Social Risk Employee health and safety risks, as well as the impact of operations on communities, may result in workplace safety issues and adverse impacts on the communities where the company operates. 3) Governance Risk Failure to comply with corporate governance standards or strictly control systems may affect maintaining trust with customers and stakeholders. It may also expose the company to risks from non-compliance with IT security standards or personal data protection laws. | • Reputation and Image Impact: Non-compliance with environmental regulations or unsustainable operations may negatively impact the company's reputation and lead to a loss of trust from customers and stakeholders. • Financial Impact: Non-compliance with laws or regulations related to the environment or safety may result in fines or expenses for process improvements to ensure compliance, including increased costs associated with unsustainable operations. • Safety Risks: In the event of accidents, health issues arising from operations, or negative impacts on the community due to business operations, the company may face costs related to damage restoration, as well as a loss of trust from employees and the community. • Operational Disruption: Failure to comply with corporate governance standards or a lack of IT controls and personal data protection may lead to problems that prevent the company from operating normally or expose it to legal violations. | - Closely monitor government laws, regulations, and policies related to the environment. Develop a Corporate Social Responsibility & Sustainability Policy and encourage employee participation in activities such as waste separation campaigns, energy reduction, and paper minimization. - Establish a Safety, Occupational Health, and Working Environment Committee. Provide health benefits such as annual health check-ups, fitness/dental discounts, etc. Provide public liability insurance to cover potential risks to the community. Establish a Welfare Committee to oversee and continuously develop employee welfare. Establish a Corporate Governance Policy and communicate it to employees. Establish a Corporate Governance Committee to oversee sustainability, recruitment, and compensation. Update ISO 27001 to the latest version and conduct regular internal audits. Train employees on IT Security and control according to ITGC and PDPA standards. | 1717 · Description: ESG risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Emerging Risks: Risks from the advancement of Artificial Intelligence (AI) that may displace human labor. | Technological advancements, particularly in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Automation, have led some industries to reduce their reliance on human labor and utilize robots or AI instead. The company has adapted by developing technologies to enhance business operations, such as Automate System, Chat GPT, and AI Matching System for matching candidates with suitable job positions. Furthermore, Digital Signature technology has been implemented in employment contract processing to streamline procedures and enhance the convenience of human resource management. | • Reduced demand for certain types of labor: The adoption of AI and automation to replace human labor may result in the displacement of some jobs or a decrease in labor demand. | - Technological Development for Enhanced Efficiency: PRTR has adopted technologies such as Automate System, ChatGPT, and AI Matching System to match candidates with suitable job positions. - Utilizing Digital Signature: To reduce steps and enhance convenience in human resource management by implementing Digital Signature technology in employment contract preparation. | 737 · Other name: Advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI) · Description: Other · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Emerging Risk: Risk of labor shortages due to demographic changes | The entry into an aging society results in a decline in the working-age population while the elderly population increases. This may lead to labor shortages in some business sectors and increase the difficulty in finding personnel who meet the required qualifications. | • Labor shortage: As the working-age population declines, there may be problems finding employees with the skills and abilities suitable for jobs in some industries. • Difficulty in competing for qualified personnel: The company may have to compete with other organizations to attract and retain highly skilled employees. | - Building Networks with Talent Sources: The company has established collaborations with universities and educational institutions to serve as a reserve of personnel with the required skills and knowledge. - Developing the Potential of the New Generation Workforce: The company has implemented CSR projects that focus on developing the potential of the new generation workforce to meet the needs of the future labor market. | 752 · Description: Impact from population structure · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |

